The Dallas Cowboys are implementing substantial alterations to their quarterback depth chart in anticipation of the 2025 NFL season. Following an unsatisfactory period in San Francisco, the Cowboys acquired Trey Lance with the optimistic goal of nurturing him into a viable backup for Dak Prescott.

Nevertheless, merely 18 months later, it seems the Cowboys are ready to sever ties with Lance, as Stephen Jones, the CEO and co-owner of the Cowboys, indicated that they foresee Lance departing in free agency in March.

An Ephemeral Experiment

The Trey Lance situation in Dallas has not unfolded as anticipated. Lance, who was chosen third overall by the San Francisco 49ers in the 2021 NFL Draft, was traded to the Cowboys in an effort to enhance the depth and potential development within their quarterback lineup. However, his tenure with the Cowboys has been underwhelming, leading to the conclusion that his future may lie outside of Dallas.

Stephen Jones addressed the Cowboys’ plans openly in an interview with The Dallas Morning News, stating, “We took a shot at Trey and wanted to do that. We think the world of Trey. But us having Dak [Prescott] signed up for the long-term, I think he’s probably going to be looking for something different.” 

This remark underscores the reality facing the Cowboys. With Prescott firmly established as the starting quarterback, there is little necessity for Lance, who was initially brought in as a backup and a potential developmental player.

Although Lance was afforded an opportunity to demonstrate his capabilities, he never truly had the chance to claim the starting position. Instead, the Cowboys opted for Cooper Rush, who performed admirably as Prescott’s backup, including stepping in during injury periods.

Lance’s Limited Opportunities

Although the Cowboys acquired Lance by trading a fourth-round pick, his chances to gain significant playing time were limited. The most significant opportunity arose in Week 18, when the team finally allowed Lance to demonstrate his abilities on the field.

Unfortunately, by that time, the Cowboys’ season had already been adversely affected by Prescott’s hamstring injury earlier in the season, and Lance’s performance in a game of little consequence did not alter his prospects with the organization. 

Lance’s difficulties in securing a genuine opportunity with the Cowboys reflect the team’s assessment of his capabilities. It is evident that Dallas was never fully committed to Lance as a viable long-term solution.

While the initial trade for Lance appeared to be a low-risk decision with considerable upside, it has become apparent that the Cowboys do not consider him part of their future strategy.

The Cowboys intend to select a quarterback during the draft in April

As Lance appears to be departing from Dallas, the Cowboys are proactively strategizing for the future. Stephen Jones has confirmed the team’s intention to pursue a quarterback in the forthcoming 2025 NFL Draft, with a particular emphasis on identifying a developmental talent to serve as a backup to Prescott.

Although the Cowboys have not disclosed their specific draft position for selecting a quarterback, Jones articulated a clear objective to secure a young player who can be nurtured for future contributions. 

“Our aim is to acquire a young quarterback in the draft,” Jones stated. “The exact position remains uncertain. This is why we traded a fourth-round pick for Trey. It seems that quarterbacks, even those we consider in the fourth round, tend to be selected much earlier than anticipated.” 

This emphasis on acquiring a young quarterback indicates that the Cowboys are focused on long-term development while ensuring a dependable backup is available. Despite the 2025 draft class potentially lacking elite quarterback prospects, Dallas is dedicated to identifying a developmental player capable of stepping in when necessary.

The Prospects for Cooper Rush

The Cowboys have made it evident that they intend to draft a quarterback, yet they are confronted with a significant issue concerning their current backup, Cooper Rush. Rush, who performed commendably in relief of Prescott during his injury, is approaching free agency in 2025.

Jones recognized Rush’s value to the organization, stating, “You know how much we think of Cooper. We just don’t know what he’s going to cost. When we’re paying Dak what we’re paying him, unfortunately, we do have to go cheap there.”

The importance of Cooper Rush to the Cowboys is undeniable. In the 2024 season, he stepped in for Prescott during a series of games, achieving a 4-4 record as a starter. Throughout his career, Rush has demonstrated his ability to rise to the occasion, leading the team to several crucial victories. His dependability as a backup quarterback has been essential for the Cowboys, particularly in light of Prescott’s injury history.

Nevertheless, as Jones pointed out, the financial implications of Prescott’s long-term contract may hinder the Cowboys’ ability to keep Rush at a cost that fits within their financial framework. With Prescott already commanding a substantial salary, extending Rush’s contract could further complicate the team’s salary cap situation.

The Challenge of the Backup Quarterback Role

As the Cowboys assess their quarterback situation, the significance of having a reliable backup behind Prescott cannot be overstated. Throughout the years, Dallas has experienced firsthand the necessity of maintaining a competent backup. Prescott has endured several season-ending injuries during his career, and his absence has frequently left the Cowboys in search of solutions at the quarterback position. 

Cooper Rush has demonstrated his reliability as a secondary option; however, with his impending free agency, there is a risk that Dallas may lose him to another franchise. Considering the financial implications of retaining Rush, it is reasonable for the Cowboys to explore the draft for a more cost-effective backup alternative. By selecting a quarterback in the later rounds, Dallas could acquire a promising talent while managing their budget effectively.

The Significance of Depth in the Quarterback Role

As the 2025 season approaches, the Cowboys’ strategy regarding quarterback depth will be a significant point of emphasis. Although Dak Prescott is securely positioned as the starting quarterback, the necessity of having a competent backup cannot be overstated. In a time when injuries can significantly impact a team’s success, possessing a dependable quarterback is crucial for a franchise with championship goals.

The Cowboys recognize this reality and are proactively working to ensure they are equipped for any situation that may arise. Whether through selecting a player in the draft or pursuing options in free agency, Dallas is committed to preserving stability at the quarterback position while also planning for the future.

Expert Editorial comment

As March draws near, the quarterback situation for the Cowboys is expected to undergo further changes. The likely exit of Trey Lance indicates a shift, while Dallas’ intention to select a quarterback in April demonstrates their dedication to nurturing talent in this critical position.

With uncertainty surrounding Cooper Rush’s future, the Cowboys must carefully evaluate their options for the backup role behind Prescott. 

At this juncture, the primary objective is to ensure that the Cowboys are well-prepared for the challenges that lie ahead. Whether through the draft or free agency, the organization aims to construct a quarterback lineup that can effectively support Dak Prescott and ensure long-term stability for the team.

With the 2025 season approaching, it is imperative for Dallas to make strategic decisions that will keep their championship aspirations alive.