In the ongoing debate about the best quarterback, a bold new opinion has reignited conversations among fans and analysts alike. Shedeur Sanders, a fifth-round pick by the Cleveland Browns, has been the subject of widespread scrutiny since slipping in the 2025 NFL Draft.
While many assumed his late selection meant a lack of confidence in his abilities, former NFL General Manager Scot McCloughan strongly disagrees. His recent comments have not only challenged popular opinion but have also added fuel to Sanders’ determination to prove doubters wrong.
The NFL Draft Slide That Sparked Controversy
Despite being viewed by some analysts, including ESPN’s Mel Kiper Jr., as the top quarterback talent in the draft, Shedeur Sanders found himself selected deep into the fifth round.
The Cleveland Browns ultimately took a chance on the Colorado standout, potentially getting a first-round caliber player at a steep discount. Naturally, this sparked widespread debate.
Many critics were quick to point to his draft position as evidence of shortcomings in his game. In contrast, others acknowledged that the draft process doesn’t always reflect future success, especially at the quarterback position.
For Sanders, this draft-day tumble became both a challenge and an opportunity.
Scot McCloughan’s Eye-Opening Prediction
Transitioning from general skepticism to outright endorsement, Scot McCloughan’s recent remarks have thrown a spotlight back on Sanders. In a conversation on Pacman Jones’ podcast, McCloughan confidently stated, “I think he’ll be the best quarterback out of this draft.”
This wasn’t a passing comment. Instead, it was a definitive stance from a seasoned executive with a proven track record. By suggesting Sanders could outperform higher-selected peers like Cam Ward, Jaxson Dart, Tyler Shough, Jalen Milroe, and Dillon Gabriel, McCloughan drew a clear line
His faith in Sanders is rooted in more than just hype; it’s based on his ability to evaluate talent, something he’s done for decades at the highest level.
Learning Before Leading
Although Sanders isn’t expected to start immediately, that might be a blessing in disguise. Being part of a crowded quarterback room in Cleveland could afford him the chance to absorb knowledge, adjust to the professional level, and develop at his own pace.
Even Tom Brady, arguably the best quarterback in NFL history, began his career on the bench. In much the same way, Sanders can bide his time, learn the system, and wait for the right moment to showcase his skills. When that opportunity comes, it will be up to him to grab it firmly.
Support from Draft Experts
Further cementing belief in Sanders is ESPN’s Mel Kiper Jr., who notably had him ranked as the top quarterback in the draft class. Kiper’s evaluation aligns closely with McCloughan’s, offering another layer of credibility to the idea that Sanders was undervalued.
Although his draft slide may have been disappointing, it certainly wasn’t a reflection of unanimous opinion.
More importantly, it means the Browns may have struck gold. While others spent first-round picks on signal callers, Cleveland waited and still landed a player some experts had at the very top of their boards.
Shedeur’s Opportunity to Rewrite His Narrative
Looking ahead, Sanders has a unique chance to redefine how people view his career. Through persistence, preparation, and performance, he can shift the narrative from overlooked to overachiever. As pressure mounts, his ability to stay poised and focused will be tested.
Yet, as McCloughan and Kiper both suggest, Sanders possesses the tools and mindset to thrive. If given the chance, he may very well emerge as the best quarterback from his draft class not just by talent, but by career longevity and impact.
Shedeur Sanders and the Path to Becoming the Best Quarterback
While the road won’t be easy, Sanders is already in a position that fosters growth. Moreover, the support of former executives and analysts offers a psychological boost, serving as motivation to prove them right. If he continues to develop, adjusts to the speed of the NFL, and embraces mentorship, his potential is limitless.
Underdog Stories Are NFL Staples
Historically, the NFL has been shaped by unexpected breakout stars. Players like Russell Wilson and Dak Prescott came into the league with little fanfare but became franchise quarterbacks. If Sanders follows a similar trajectory, McCloughan’s bold prediction may turn out to be prophetic.
Expert Editorial Comment
Although he wasn’t picked in the early rounds, Shedeur Sanders’ story is far from written. Given his talent, mindset, and now the backing of respected voices in the league, the foundation is set. Whether or not he becomes the best quarterback remains to be seen, but the possibility is very real.