The Cleveland Browns have secured quarterback Kenny Pickett, and with Deshaun Watson anticipated to be sidelined for the entire 2025 season, Pickett is presented with a chance to demonstrate his capabilities as a starting quarterback in the NFL once again. Following an unpredictable beginning to his career with the Pittsburgh Steelers and a short period in Philadelphia, Pickett is prepared to seize this new opportunity.

Kenny Pickett’s Attitude: Prepared for Competition

Amid the ambiguity regarding the quarterback situation for the Browns, Kenny Pickett maintains a strong belief in his capabilities. He has candidly conveyed his conviction that he remains a quarterback worthy of a starting position, despite facing challenges in the past. 

“I consider myself a starter,” Pickett remarked. “I anticipate that they will likely bring in another veteran, along with other potential changes, but I am eager to be here and compete against anyone.” 

Such confidence is essential for any quarterback joining a new team. Pickett recognizes the intense competition ahead, especially with reports indicating that the Browns are exploring options for other veteran quarterbacks, necessitating that he demonstrate his skills once more.

The Trade: An Emerging Opportunity for Pickett

The Browns have acquired Kenny Pickett in a trade that involved sending quarterback Dorian Thompson-Robinson and a fifth-round draft pick to the opposing team. This transaction represents a mutual exchange of quarterbacks who have yet to realize their full potential.

Although Pickett experienced some success as a starter in Pittsburgh, the Steelers decided to part ways with him, resulting in his move to Philadelphia, where he served in a limited capacity behind Jalen Hurts. Now, as he joins the Browns, he is presented with a new opportunity to compete for a starting role.

With Deshaun Watson currently unavailable, the quarterback situation in Cleveland is quite open. The team may consider acquiring another experienced player, such as Russell Wilson, who has recently met with the Browns.

Furthermore, with the second overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, Cleveland is positioned to select a potential franchise quarterback. Despite these options, Pickett is ready to embrace the challenges that lie ahead.

Pickett’s Capabilities and Advantages

Throughout his time with the Steelers, Pickett achieved a record of 14 wins and 10 losses as a starting quarterback. He completed 62.6% of his passes, accumulating a total of 4,474 yards, along with 13 touchdowns and 13 interceptions.

Although his performance metrics may not stand out significantly, he exhibited commendable leadership and composure in high-pressure situations. 

Pickett’s style of play is frequently described as that of a game manager rather than an explosive playmaker. While he may not possess exceptional arm strength or the ability to create dynamic plays, he is recognized for his sound decision-making and ability to remain calm during critical moments. These attributes could be advantageous for a Browns team that boasts a robust defense and a reliable offensive supporting cast.

The Quarterback Scenario for the Browns

The Browns are anticipated to explore various quarterback options as they approach the 2025 season. Although Kenny Pickett is currently positioned as the starting quarterback, the organization is actively assessing alternatives, which include both free agents and potential draft candidates. 

With Russell Wilson making a visit to Cleveland, the team may contemplate acquiring the seasoned player as a possible starter.

Furthermore, holding the No. 2 pick in the upcoming draft provides an opportunity to select a leading quarterback prospect, such as Caleb Williams or Drake Maye. Either of these developments would create considerable competition for Pickett.

Nevertheless, Pickett remains undeterred by the prospect of competition. He stated, “As long as I have a chance to compete, that’s all you can ask for.” This attitude will be crucial as he aims to establish his position in Cleveland.

Analyzing Pickett’s Role within the Browns’ Offensive Scheme

The offensive strategy of the Browns, under the guidance of head coach Kevin Stefanski, prioritizes efficiency, prudent decision-making, and game control. These attributes complement Pickett’s abilities as a quarterback.

Although Pickett may not be known for making spectacular plays, he possesses the capability to manage an offense proficiently.

The Browns boast a formidable rushing game spearheaded by Nick Chubb, in addition to a reliable group of receivers that includes Amari Cooper, Elijah Moore, and David Njoku. Should Pickett establish a rapport with these offensive talents and implement the system effectively, he has the potential to achieve success in Cleveland.

Areas for Improvement for Pickett

Pickett has demonstrated potential; however, there are several key areas that require enhancement for him to establish himself as a starting quarterback. 

Deep Ball Precision – A significant critique of Pickett has been his lack of reliability with long-range throws. By improving his accuracy on deep passes, he can effectively challenge opposing defenses and create additional scoring opportunities for the team.

Decision-Making Under Duress – Although Pickett has exhibited poise, he has occasionally made questionable choices when faced with intense pressure. Enhancing his awareness in the pocket and minimizing avoidable turnovers will be crucial for his development.

Consistency – Throughout his tenure with the Steelers, Pickett has experienced periods of commendable performance but has struggled with maintaining consistency. To secure a starting position, he must deliver high-level performances consistently each week.

The Path Forward for Pickett

For Kenny Pickett, the 2025 season marks a pivotal moment in his professional journey. Should he seize this opportunity and deliver strong performances, he could rejuvenate his career and position himself as a viable long-term solution for the Browns. Conversely, if he encounters difficulties, he risks returning to a backup role. 

The Browns’ management has indicated their willingness to foster competition for the quarterback position. It remains uncertain whether Pickett can meet this challenge, but one fact is clear: he is determined to demonstrate his capabilities and secure his role in Cleveland’s future.

Expert Editorial Comment

Kenny Pickett embarks on a new chapter with the Cleveland Browns, and although his position is not yet clearly defined, he is ready to vie for the starting role.

With Deshaun Watson unavailable, the Browns are expected to consider all possibilities, but Pickett’s resolve and experience may provide him with a competitive advantage. Regardless of whether he secures the starting position or acts as a transitional quarterback, this season will be pivotal in shaping his career in the NFL.