An NFL Insider has disclosed the underlying motivation for the Indianapolis Colts decision to offer Daniel Jones a contract worth $14 million per year, igniting intense discussions among fans and analysts alike. This move has polarized opinions, with some labeling it as excessive while others perceive it as a calculated strategy. What factors influenced this signing, and what implications does it hold for the franchise’s future?
The Indianapolis Colts’ Quarterback Dilemma
In recent seasons, the Indianapolis Colts have grappled with instability at the quarterback position. Their promising young quarterback, Anthony Richardson, has faced challenges due to injuries and inconsistent performance.
In 2024, Richardson recorded more interceptions than touchdowns, raising alarms within the Colts’ management. As a result, the franchise sought a dependable alternative, ultimately leading them to Daniel Jones.
The Rationale for Choosing Daniel Jones
A Strategic Safety Measure
The NFL Insider indicates that the Colts’ front office views Jones as a crucial investment. Although Richardson is still seen as a potential franchise quarterback, concerns about his durability linger.
By securing Jones as a backup option, the Colts aim to ensure stability and experience, safeguarding the team’s performance in the event that Richardson is unable to deliver.
Experience and Potential
While Jones may not be the most dynamic quarterback in the league, he has demonstrated his skills effectively. In 2022, he led the New York Giants to an unexpected playoff victory against the Minnesota Vikings.
His capacity to make plays using both his arm and legs positions him as a dual-threat quarterback, capable of challenging defenses. Although he has faced difficulties in recent seasons, the Colts are optimistic about his unexploited potential.

Internal Reactions
Relief Among Colts’ Management
Jeremy Fowler, a respected NFL insider, provided insights into the atmosphere within the Colts’ organization following the signing of Jones. He noted that some members felt a sense of relief, as having an experienced quarterback like Jones offers a safety net should Richardson continue to experience injuries or inconsistency.
The Quarterback Battle
While many believe that Jones will serve as a backup, there is increasing speculation that he might compete with Richardson for the starting position. Fowler disclosed on The Rich Eisen Show that the Colts’ coaching staff is maintaining an open perspective.
Should Jones perform well during training camp and the preseason, he could potentially secure the starting role.
Anthony Richardson’s Reaction
In light of the excitement surrounding Jones, Richardson’s team remains composed. Fowler recounted a discussion with an individual close to Richardson, who expressed that the young quarterback is not concerned about competition.
“They mentioned that Anthony is unfazed by the prospect of Joe Montana joining the team; he is determined to secure that position.”
This indicates that Richardson is ready to compete vigorously and demonstrate his capabilities.
The Broader Perspective for the Colts
A Strategic Business Decision
The Colts’ choice to offer Daniel Jones a contract worth $14 million annually may appear excessive to some, yet it aligns with a broader strategy.
NFL teams must always be prepared for unexpected events, and acquiring a reliable backup is a forward-thinking measure. As Fowler noted, the Colts are ensuring they are well-prepared rather than reacting impulsively.
A Lesson from the Raiders
Fowler drew a parallel between the Colts’ strategy and that of the Las Vegas Raiders from the previous season. Although the Raiders had young quarterback Aiden O’Connell on their roster, they chose to start veteran Gardner Minshew.
This decision proved beneficial, and the Colts may aim to achieve similar success with Jones and Richardson.
Implications for the 2025 Season
The Competition Heats Up
With both quarterbacks eager to establish their worth, the forthcoming season is set to be thrilling for Colts supporters. If Richardson maintains his health and hones his skills, he is likely to keep his starting role.
Conversely, should he struggle, Jones may take advantage of the situation and step in.
A Franchise in Transition
The Colts possess a strong roster; however, their success will significantly depend on the quarterback role. Whether it is Richardson or Daniel Jones, the team requires a reliable leader at the helm.
The coaching staff faces a pivotal choice that will be influenced by performance, health, and team dynamics.
Expert Editorial Comment
The NFL Insider uncovers the underlying strategy behind the Indianapolis Colts’ decision to pay Daniel Jones $14 million annually, providing insight into the team’s long-term planning. While some may question this approach, it is evident that the Colts are focusing on ensuring stability and fostering competition at the quarterback position. Regardless of whether Jones takes on the starting role or serves as an expensive backup, his involvement enhances the team’s overall prospects.