The Instant reactions to Colts’ picks in latest 5-round 2025 NFL mock draft reveal some intriguing decisions by the franchise, ones that could shape the roster for years to come.
With the NFL landscape constantly evolving, every draft presents an opportunity to build, adapt, and surprise.
The Indianapolis Colts have made their choices, and now it’s time to dive deep and evaluate each one from the first-round linebacker selection to a potential game-changing running back late in the fifth round.
In this article, we’ll break down each pick made by the Colts, provide immediate reactions, and discuss how these additions align with team needs, scheme fit, and long-term planning.
Transitioning from pick to pick, our insights aim to provide a holistic view of the Colts’ draft approach under their current regime.
Round 1, Pick 14 Jihaad Campbell, LB, Alabama
First and foremost, the Colts’ decision to use their top pick on linebacker Jihaad Campbell sends a clear message: they are committed to bolstering the heart of their defense.
At pick 14, some fans may have expected a flashier selection perhaps a wide receiver or cornerback but the need at linebacker couldn’t be ignored.
Campbell’s Fit and Versatility
Campbell is more than just a solid tackler. He is a modern-day linebacker, built for today’s NFL. He’s athletic, rangy, and displays exceptional instincts both in coverage and in run defense.
Furthermore, Campbell’s ability to contribute in multiple phases of the game blitzing, coverage, and sideline-to-sideline pursuit makes him a valuable chess piece.
According to Chad Reuter, “Zaire Franklin operates in the middle of the Colts defense, which means Campbell can use his athleticism to make plays as a pass rusher, in coverage and when tracking down run plays to the outside.”
This endorsement highlights the complementary role Campbell can play alongside Franklin.
Why Drafting a Linebacker Early Makes Sense
Despite linebacker not being a premium position in today’s pass-heavy league, the lack of depth in this year’s draft class might have pushed the Colts’ hand.
There’s also uncertainty surrounding internal options like Jaylon Carlies, making this pick even more logical. Because of this, securing a high-upside prospect early in the draft could be seen as proactive team-building rather than a luxury move.
Round 2, Pick 45 – Jordan Burch, DE, Oregon
As we move into Day 2 of the draft, the Colts snag a defensive end who could quietly become a star. Jordan Burch brings immediate depth to a unit that saw Dayo Odeyingbo leave for the Bears in free agency.
Planning for the Future
The edge rusher position might not seem like an urgent concern, but the 2026 season could bring massive changes. Kwity Paye, Samson Ebukam, and Tyquan Lewis are all entering free agency. Therefore, having Burch on the roster helps future-proof the pass rush.
Notably, Burch has averaged 33 pressures per year over the past three seasons and is equally adept at defending the run. His versatility also mimics that of Odeyingbo, as he can shift inside on passing downs. Clearly, this is a pick with both present and future value in mind.
Round 3, Pick 80 – Elijah Arroyo, TE, Miami
The Colts continue to build their offensive weaponry by adding tight end Elijah Arroyo. Although not considered one of the top-tier prospects heading into the draft, Arroyo’s production speaks volumes.
Offensive Weapon with Big-Play Ability
Averaging nearly 17 yards per reception in 2024, Arroyo brings a vertical element to the tight end position.
While Shane Steichen’s offense values tight ends who can block and catch, Arroyo’s run-blocking remains a work in progress. That said, his ability to generate yards after the catch makes him an exciting option.
Given how the Colts’ tight ends have struggled to create separation and big plays, Arroyo fills a void that has lingered for several seasons. The pick not only boosts the passing game but also creates flexibility in offensive formations.
Round 4, Pick 117 – Dylan Fairchild, IOL, Georgia
In the fourth round, the Colts address a critical need by selecting interior offensive lineman Dylan Fairchild. With Will Fries leaving for Minnesota, the guard position needed reinforcement.
Steady and Dependable
Fairchild has mainly played left guard at Georgia but possesses experience on the right side as well. According to PFF, he allowed only one sack and 14 pressures over the past two seasons.
His technique and consistency as a pass blocker make him a strong candidate to compete for a starting job in training camp.
Additionally, Fairchild’s background in the SEC provides confidence that he’s faced elite-level defensive competition. That will be invaluable as he transitions to the NFL.
His physicality and work ethic should fit in seamlessly with the Colts’ offensive line identity.
Round 5, Pick 151 – Jarquez Hunter, RB, Auburn
The Colts close out their five-round draft haul by selecting Auburn running back Jarquez Hunter. While Jonathan Taylor remains the unquestioned starter, depth and versatility were missing behind him.
Home Run Hitter with Receiving Skills
Hunter ranked 19th in missed tackles forced and eighth in rushes of 10-plus yards during the 2024 season.
These numbers demonstrate his ability to break tackles and generate explosive plays. More importantly, with 90 career targets, Hunter has shown he can be a reliable pass-catcher out of the backfield.
Khalil Herbert’s arrival shouldn’t stop the Colts from adding talent, especially in a backfield where injuries and workload management are always concerns.
Hunter brings a dynamic skill set that could shine in specific packages or third-down situations.
Instant reactions to Colts’ picks in latest 5-round 2025 NFL mock draft
The Instant reactions to Colts’ picks in latest 5-round 2025 NFL mock draft show a well-balanced approach by the front office.
While some fans might have preferred flashier selections, the Colts addressed real needs with players who are ready to contribute immediately.
Balanced Across the Board
Defense first: The selection of Campbell and Burch early on reaffirms the Colts’ commitment to maintaining a strong defense, especially under Lou Anarumo.
Offensive reinforcements: Adding Arroyo, Fairchild, and Hunter gives quarterback Anthony Richardson more tools and support in 2025.
Draft strategy: The picks were made with both short- and long-term views in mind. Depth was prioritized, but so was future flexibility, especially with contract expirations looming in 2026.
What This Means for the 2025 Season
As we transition toward training camp, these new additions will have a chance to earn their place on the roster. Jihaad Campbell may step into a starting role right away, while Burch and Fairchild could be key rotational pieces.
Although not every draft pick becomes a star, these five selections align well with the Colts’ vision for the future.
Steichen’s offense and Anarumo’s defense require versatility, athleticism, and high football IQ traits that each of these picks seems to possess.
Expert Editorial Comment
The Instant reactions to Colts’ picks in latest 5-round 2025 NFL mock draft highlight a draft class that is pragmatic yet promising. It wasn’t about making headlines; it was about building a foundation.
While time will ultimately tell how successful this class will be, initial impressions suggest the Colts drafted with intention, awareness of need, and a clear vision for the future. And that is how winning organizations are built.