The 2025 NFL free agency period continues to unveil unexpected developments as teams finalize agreements aimed at enhancing their rosters.
While the initial phase of free agency was dominated by high-profile players securing substantial contracts, Day 4 shifted its focus to strategic acquisitions and value-oriented deals. Numerous teams executed well-considered moves, seeking to bolster their depth and address critical needs.
Among the notable transactions was the Kansas City Chiefs’ signing of a new backup quarterback for Patrick Mahomes, alongside the Philadelphia Eagles’ efforts to strengthen their defense.
These moves have the potential to create a significant impact moving forward. Below, we evaluate the most important transactions of the day and assign grades based on their anticipated effectiveness.
Chiefs Sign Gardner Minshew as Backup QB for Patrick Mahomes
A highlight of Day 4 in the 2025 NFL free agency was the Kansas City Chiefs’ choice to bring in Gardner Minshew as a backup for Mahomes.
After a season with the Colts in 2024, Minshew is poised to contribute his experience and playmaking skills to Kansas City. Despite facing challenges with ball security last season, his confidence and adaptability position him as a valuable asset within Andy Reid’s offensive framework.
Grade: A-
Eagles Acquire Adoree’ Jackson for Defensive Reinforcement
In light of Darius Slay and Isaiah Rodgers departing in free agency, the Philadelphia Eagles recognized the need for additional support in their secondary. They addressed this gap by signing former Giants and Titans cornerback Adoree’ Jackson.
His extensive experience as a starter makes him a significant addition, particularly as the Eagles develop a young secondary. Furthermore, Jackson’s background in special teams enhances his versatility within the team.
Grade: B
Texans Acquire Offensive Guard Ed Ingram
The Houston Texans made a calculated decision by trading for offensive lineman Ed Ingram in exchange for a sixth-round pick in 2026. This acquisition has sparked some discussion, particularly since the Texans recently parted ways with Kenyon Green, who had a superior pass protection rating.
Nevertheless, the trade’s low cost is appealing, and the Texans are optimistic that Ingram can enhance his performance in a new setting.
Grade: C-
Raiders Sign Veteran RB Raheem Mostert
Following the exits of Alexander Mattison and Ameer Abdullah, the Las Vegas Raiders aimed to bolster their running back lineup. They chose to sign veteran Raheem Mostert, known for his explosive speed but also facing concerns regarding his durability.
At 32 years old, Mostert is coming off a less productive season; however, his prior experience of surpassing 1,000 rushing yards indicates he can still be effective within the right system.
Grade: B-
Steelers Re-sign Mason Rudolph as Backup QB
The Pittsburgh Steelers’ choice to retain Mason Rudolph ensures continuity at the quarterback position.
However, it also prompts inquiries regarding their long-term plans. While Rudolph has shown resilience in previous seasons, he has often been passed over for starting opportunities. This decision appears to be a temporary solution until the Steelers find a more permanent option at quarterback.
Grade: C
Eagles Take a Risk on Joshua Uche
This offseason, the Philadelphia Eagles’ defensive line experienced considerable changes, with notable departures such as Josh Sweat and C.J. Gardner-Johnson. In light of these changes, the Eagles have brought in Joshua Uche, a promising young pass rusher from New England.
Although Uche has not yet served as a full-time starter, his potential is significant. With proper development under defensive coordinator Vic Fangio, he has the opportunity to evolve into a dependable contributor.
Grade: B
Expert Editorial Comment
The 2025 NFL free agency period is progressing, with teams making strategic decisions. While certain signings offer immediate enhancements, others carry inherent risks and uncertainties. The Chiefs have bolstered their quarterback depth, the Eagles have strengthened their secondary, and the Texans have taken a chance on an offensive lineman. As teams finalize their rosters, these transactions will be closely examined in the upcoming season.